Printify and Printd Mint are two of the biggest names in the print-on-demand space — but which one should you use for your online store?
After reviewing dozens of ecommerce platforms and POD providers over the years, I’ve found that Printify is the better choice for sellers who want to scale quickly with a large product catalog and global fulfillment, while Printd Mint is ideal for brands focused on premium print quality and consistent branding.
In this review, I’ll compare both platforms across the key areas that matter most: product selection, print quality, integrations, shipping speed, branding tools, and pricing.
Whether you're just starting out or growing an established store, this guide will help you decide which platform fits your strategy best.
Let’s get into it.
Quick Comparison: Printify vs Printd Mint
| Feature | Printify | Printd Mint |
|---|---|---|
| Overall rating | ★★★★☆ (4.5) | ★★★★☆ (4.2) |
| Best for | Scaling fast, global reach | Quality control, branding |
| Product catalog | 850+ products | 150–200 curated products |
| Integrations | Shopify, Etsy, Woo, eBay, more | Shopify, Etsy only |
| Branding options | Limited (varies by provider) | Built-in branding tools |
| Pricing model | Free or $29/mo Premium | Free to use |
| Print consistency | Varies by provider | Consistent across orders |
| Fulfillment locations | Global | USA only |
| Avg production time | 2–7 business days | 2–4 business days |
Best for Product Variety: Printify
If you want options, Printify gives you plenty. Its catalog includes over 850 products, thanks to partnerships with more than 90 global print providers.
Whether you’re selling mugs, hoodies, yoga mats, or framed wall art, you’ll find it here. I’ve used Printify to launch seasonal products fast and test multiple niches — it’s ideal for that kind of agile selling.
By contrast, Printd Mint offers around 150–200 products, mostly in the apparel and home goods space. The selection is more curated, which is great for brand consistency but limiting if you want variety or need to expand your catalog quickly.
The Winner
Printify wins for product range. It gives you more choices, which is key when testing markets or building a high-SKU store.
Best for Print Quality: Printd Mint
Printify works as a middleman between you and print providers. That gives you access to many options — but it also means quality can vary widely.
Some vendors like Monster Digital and Print Geek offer crisp results, but others can be inconsistent. I’ve had orders arrive with faded prints or subpar packaging when I didn’t vet the provider carefully.
Printd Mint, on the other hand, handles all fulfillment in-house. This gives them tight quality control, and it shows. My samples from Printd Mint were consistently sharp, colour-accurate, and well-packed.
For brands focused on repeat customers and low return rates, that consistency matters.
The Winner
Printd Mint wins for quality. If every order needs to meet the same standard, it’s the safer choice.
Best for Speed and Shipping: Printd Mint (US) vs Printify (Global)
When it comes to fulfillment speed, Printd Mint generally ships orders within 2–4 business days, all from US-based facilities.
That gives it an edge for domestic orders. My US customers often received packages within 5 business days, which helped with retention and reviews.
Printify’s speed depends on the provider and their location. Some ship within 2 days, others take a week. If you’re selling worldwide, Printify is a better bet — its global network includes providers in the US, UK, Europe, and Australia.
The Winner
Printd Mint wins for US-based stores that want fast, predictable shipping.
Printify wins for international stores or brands with customers across multiple regions.
Best for Ecommerce Integration: Printify
When building your store, integration matters. Printify integrates with:
- Shopify
- Etsy
- WooCommerce
- BigCommerce
- eBay
- Wix
- Squarespace (via Order Desk)
- Custom via API
Printd Mint is much more limited — it only works with Shopify and Etsy, with no API access. This made it harder for me to connect Printd Mint to other storefronts or marketplaces. If you're not on Shopify or Etsy, it's not an option.
The Winner
Printify wins hands down for integrations. It plays well with more platforms and offers API flexibility.
Best for Pricing & Profit Margins: Printify with Premium
Printify’s free plan is great for testing, but serious sellers will benefit from Printify Premium at $29/month. It gives up to 20% off base product costs, which can boost margins significantly. For example:
| Product | Printify Premium Price | Printd Mint Price |
|---|---|---|
| Unisex tee | $7.99–$9.49 | $12.95–$14.95 |
| Hoodie | $18.99–$24.00 | $27.00–$32.00 |
| 11oz Mug | $4.10–$6.50 | $9.00–$11.00 |
Printd Mint doesn’t charge monthly fees, which is great if you’re new. But its base costs are higher, which makes it harder to scale unless you’re charging premium prices.
The Winner
Printify wins for margins and pricing flexibility — especially if you’re selling in volume.
Printd Mint is fine for boutique brands with higher price points.
Best for Branding Options: Printd Mint
One of the biggest drawbacks of Printify is that branding options depend on the provider. Some let you add custom neck tags, packing slips, or inserts. Others don’t. It’s hit or miss, and not ideal if branding is central to your customer experience.
Printd Mint offers built-in branding options, including:
- Custom neck labels
- Branded packing slips
- Packaging inserts
It feels more like a full-service POD brand partner. For me, this made a big difference when building a cohesive experience from cart to unboxing.
The Winner
Printd Mint wins for brand consistency. You control how your products look and feel when they arrive.
Best for Support: Tie
Printify offers 24/7 live chat, a big help center, and responsive support. But as a platform, they act as the middleman — which can slow down issue resolution. I’ve had situations where I waited days while Printify contacted the provider on my behalf.
Printd Mint is slower (email only), but they’re more hands-on. When I had a branding issue, they walked me through options and followed up personally. Support feels smaller but more personal.
The Winner
It’s a tie.
- Use Printify if you want quick replies and round-the-clock help.
- Use Printd Mint if you want deeper support with branding or setup.
The Final Verdict: Which One Should You Use?
Both Printify and Printd Mint have their strengths — and your choice depends on how you want to grow your store.
Use Printify if you:
- Want more products to test and scale
- Need multiple platform integrations
- Sell globally or want provider flexibility
- Care about maximising margins via Premium
Use Printd Mint if you:
- Want consistent quality across all orders
- Focus on a branded unboxing experience
- Sell mainly in the US
- Prioritise quality over catalog size
If you're launching a lean, focused brand and care deeply about branding — go with Printd Mint. If you're building fast, testing products, and selling internationally — Printify is the better tool.
Both are solid — it just comes down to your strategy.
Comments 0 Responses