Printful vs Printed Mint 2024: Which POD Platform is Best?

Printful vs Printed Mint: Which is the best platform for Print on Demand sellers in 2024? After experimenting with both solutions myself, I think Printful is the better option overall, with more products to choose from, and the ability to integrate with numerous sales channels.

However, Printed Mint is certainly the cheaper option overall if you’re looking for lower-cost products. In this complete comparison guide, I’ll share all the insights you need to make the best choice for your evolving business.

Key Takeaways

• Both Printed Mint and Printful are print on demand vendors that allow companies to sell customized products online.
• Although both platforms integrate with various sales channels, Printful offers more options, including the ability to sell through social media and various marketplaces.
• Both companies offer expedited shipping, though your customers may have to pay more.
• Printed Mint’s products are less expensive than the ones available from Printful, although both companies commit to delivering exceptional quality.
• Printed Mint offers more customer support options, including phone support in the US.
• Printful offers a wider selection of products in different categories, and more customization options, such as embroidery.

Printful vs Printed Mint: Pros and Cons

Printful Pros and Cons

Printed Mint Pros and Cons

Printed Mint vs Printful: Pricing and Plans

Both Printed Mint and Printful allow companies to start selling products with no monthly subscription costs. However you still need to account for the base cost of the items you sell, and Printed Mint has a slight edge in this area, as many of its products are less expensive.

Both of these companies do offer additional services for extra fees too. Printed Mint allows you to pay extra for branded packaging options and express shipping. Printful also offers express shipping, as well as support with warehousing, branding, design, and product photography.

Interestingly, Printful also offers “membership” packages, which give companies additional benefits. Both of these memberships are free if you earn a certain amount per year, however you can also pay for access to the first tier:

• Printful Growth: Free for companies with $12k annual sales, or $24.99 per month: Includes up to 20% off DTG products, 30% off other products, 7% off branding, and support with product transfer services.
• Printful Business: Exclusively available to companies with $60k+ in annual sales: Includes up to 22% off DTG products, 33% off other items, 25% off sample orders, priority support, 9% off branding, and free embroidery digitization.

Printful vs Printed Mint: The Features

Printed Mint and Printful are very similar tools. They both allow companies to access print on demand service, and integrate their solution with their existing online store. Both platforms include:

• Access to a range of customizable products: Although Printful has more product options to offer overall, including unique premium and eco-friendly options, both companies offer an extensive range. Both companies also have products made specifically in the USA.
• Integrations: Again, Printful gives you more sales channels to choose from, but both companies allow you to integrate with common ecommerce platforms and marketplaces, like Shopify, WooCommerce, and Etsy.
• Design tools: With both platforms, you’ll access easy-to-use design tools and mock-up generators to help you create and promote your custom items. Both also offer access to free resources like fonts and graphics.
• Customization options: Both companies give you various ways to customize your products and packaging. However, Printful offers more printing methods, including all-over-print and embroidery.
• Fulfillment: Each platform offers comprehensive fulfillment services, with excellent turnaround times and the option for express shipping. With both vendors, companies can ship products to customers around the world and track order progress.

However, while both companies offer very similar features, Printful is a far more robust platform. It integrates with more than double the number of platforms and sales channels than Printed Mint.

There are AI-powered design tools to help you optimize your products, and there’s a much wider catalog of unique products to choose from.

Ease of Use: Which Platform is Simpler?

I found both Printed Mint and Printful to be extremely easy to use. The design tools are excellent, with a very small learning curve, even for absolute beginners. However, I found Printful to be slightly more intuitive, thanks to the use of AI design tools that help you optimize your files.

Additionally, Printful gives you more free assets and tools, such as a solution that helps you create compelling all-over-print patterns.

As a bonus, Printful also makes it easier to sell your products on a range of channels and scale your sales strategy, with tons of one-click integrations and a dedicated API. Printed Mint, on the other hand, only integrates with a handful of platforms.

On the plus side, both platforms offer excellent templates, and mockup generators for product pages. However, I felt Printed Mint was a little more basic overall. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing for absolute beginners, as fewer features means less time spent learning how to use the platform.

However, if you’re looking for a highly scalable solution with more advanced capabilities, you’ll get better results with Printful in the long term.

Printful vs Printed Mint Product Quality and Variety

As I mentioned above, Printful does offer more variety than Printed Mint in terms of product options. However, both companies give you a wide selection of popular items to choose from, including t-shirts, sweaters, mugs, home accessories, and more.

Both companies offer premium products, as well as items specifically made in the USA, which could be helpful if you want faster production and shipping times. However, Printed Mint is a little limited in terms of the ways you can customize your products.

Printful offers options like embroidery and all-over-print, whereas Printed Mint lacks these printing choices. In terms of product quality, Printed Mint has an excellent reputation for delivering consistent quality, which explains the higher price tag of some of its items. In fact, the company boasts a 99% customer quality satisfaction rate.

Printed Mint also has an excellent reputation for quality, and both companies have strong quality assurance processes in place. Both platforms also allow you to customize packaging and branding components, to help strengthen your relationships with customers.

Printed Mint vs Printful: Customer Support

If you’re looking for fast customer service, Printful offers both email and live chat options. Plus, I’m a huge fan of the company’s incredible collection of self-help resources, which include everything from guides to FAQs, videos, and blog posts. There’s even a learner academy available for beginners.

Printed Mint does offer phone support, but it’s only available in the USA. Everyone else will be limited to contacting the team through email, as there’s no live chat option.

The customer service also isn’t available 24/7, whereas it is with Printful. Notably, Printed Mint does have a good help center, but it’s not as robust as Printful’s.

Alternatives to Printed Mint and Printful

Both Printed Mint and Printful are excellent platforms for Print on Demand, but there are also some fantastic alternatives out there to consider too. Some of my favorites include:

• Printify: Printify is one of the most popular print on demand platforms available, offering even more product options than Printful, and access to a huge network of global suppliers. However, the product quality and shipping times can sometimes vary.
• Gelato: Ideal for fast shipping and eco-friendly product collections, Gelato is another leader in the print on demand landscape. However it has fewer product options to choose from than Printful, and pricing can vary drastically.
• Teespring: If you’re looking for an easy way to start selling POD products, Teespring allows you to sell through an online marketplace, so there’s no need to set up your own online store. However, there is a lot of competition on the platform already.

Printful vs Printed Mint: Which is Best?

I think Printful is the better print-on-demand solution overall, offering exceptional product variety and customization options, powerful design tools, and the option to integrate with a wider range of platforms. While Printed Mint has some excellent features, it lacks the scalability of Printful, making it harder to grow your profit margins.

When to Use Printful

I’d recommend Printful if you’re looking for:

• A huge range of unique products and customization options
• Powerful AI-driven design tools
• Excellent integrations with a range of platforms
• Extra support and services (for a free)
• Comprehensive self-help resources and live chat support

When to Use Printed Mint

I’d suggest using Printed Mint if you’re looking for:

• Lower-cost products for potentially higher profit margins
• Fast shipping and support in the USA
• Easy integrations with platforms like Etsy and Squarespace
• Straightforward and intuitive tools
• Custom packaging and branding

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs):